BANGOR — Attorneys in the case of an Augusta man who accused a priest of sexually abusing him as a child argued before Maine’s highest court Tuesday over whether the Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland was obligated to disclose that the priest was later accused of abusing other children.

William Picher of Augusta accused Raymond Melville of sexually abusing him while he was a student at St. Mary’s School, from September 1986 to June 1988, while Melville was serving his initial assignment as assistant pastor at St. Mary’s Parish in Augusta.

Picher, now 39, filed his complaint in 2007. He also accused the diocese of covering up knowledge about previous sex abuse complaints against Melville that came to light after Picher was abused.

In 1990, a Maryland man wrote to then-Portland Bishop Joseph Gerry, saying he had been “emotionally, sexually and physically abused” as a teenager by Melville between 1980 and 1985, when Melville was a seminarian studying to be a priest in Baltimore.

Picher’s case never went to trial because Justice Donald Marden granted summary judgment in favor of the diocese last August in Kennebec County Superior Court on Picher’s claim that the diocese never disclosed the other sex-abuse complaints against Melville.

Picher is now appealing Marden’s decision to the state’s highest court, arguing that the diocese had an obligation to report the 1990 accusations against Melville.

The diocese’s attorney, Gerald Petruccelli, argued that the diocese couldn’t have engaged in a cover-up in Picher’s case because it learned too late of other allegations, years after Picher had been abused.

“The only material fact that could have made a difference here is the letter that arrived in 1990,” Petruccelli argued before the panel of Supreme Judicial Court justices.

One of Picher’s attorneys, Sumner Lipman, said after the hearing that if the high court rules in Picher’s favor, the case could have a broad impact, opening the door for other child victims of clergy sex abuse to argue that the diocese is liable by not reporting accusations as they become known.

Picher’s case differs from other Maine clergy sex abuse cases, such as those that followed the Portland diocese’s 2005 disclosure of the identities of eight deceased priests as having been accused of sexually abusing children in Maine over decades.

In those cases, the victims have a public record that the diocese had covered up abuse.

In Picher’s case, “the diocese still has not announced that this priest was a pedophile,” Lipman said.

“I think the issues are really the amount of evidence necessary to put the diocese on notice before the abuse took place,” Lipman said. “When the diocese had absolute, direct knowledge that there was sexual abuse, they did absolutely nothing to notify the parents.”

Lipman said that Picher was 12 years old when Melville began abusing him, and by the time the diocese became aware of the other abuse allegation against Melville in 1990, Picher was only 16. At that point, Picher had not yet told his parents what happened and had not received any therapy, he said.

“Our position is the harm continues to happen because he was not treated,” Lipman said.

The Supreme Judicial Court made no immediate ruling on the appeal and gave no indication of when it would rule.

Melville, now 71, defaulted after failing to respond to Picher’s 2007 court complaint and was ordered to pay Picher $4.2 million in damages.

Lipman said Picher has collected some of that money but declined to specify how much. Melville was last known to be living in North Carolina, he said.

The diocese has said previously that Melville was granted a leave of absence from active ministry in 1997 at his request.

In a separate case, Michael Fortin of Sidney, was awarded $500,000 in damages against Melville, and settled with the church for an undisclosed amount. In that case, the Maine Supreme Judicial Court ruled in 2005 that the protections of church leaders are limited when weighed against the welfare of children.

Fortin claimed he was sexually abused by Melville for seven years beginning in 1985, when Fortin was 13 and Melville was his parish priest in Augusta.

Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or to participate in the conversation. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.