In Italy, prosecutors, seemingly on leave from a comic opera, insisted that “she devil” Amanda Knox was guilty of murder, no matter what science and common sense indicated.

It took four years for justice to prevail. Yet in Maine, supposedly a land of sober Yankee rectitude, for more than 20 years Dennis Dechaine has been denied a retrial, despite the fact that 100 percent of the scientific evidence supports his claim of innocence.

With the discovery that the damning testimony of two detectives contradicted their original notes, the state’s “mountain of evidence” is revealed to be a hollow shell.

That a second jury, if allowed to hear all the evidence, would again find Dechaine guilty, is all but inconceivable. That an innocent man may have been been imprisoned ’til death for the unspeakable crime of a psychopath who, in effect, has enjoyed the protection of the state, should impel our attorney general to seek the truth, not to try to bury it.

Compared to Maine’s, the Italian system of justice appears to be a shining model of efficiency, transparency and fairness. Who would have guessed?

William Bunting


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.