AUGUSTA — The state’s human rights panel says a Waterville police sergeant was subject to illegal workplace discrimination.

Jeffrey C. Bearce worked full-time for the department for almost 23 years until his termination Feb. 18, 2011.

The case was handled Monday by the Maine Human Rights Commission. Commission investigator Domini Pham had recommended the 3-1 finding, which carries no legal consequences but may become grounds for lawsuits.

Bearce had been fighting leukemia since 2009, and was on medical leave — during which fellow employees donated vacation time so he could be paid — for about a year until the end of December 2010, when he brought to the city a note from a doctor clearing him to work without restriction.

Bearce also was approved for Maine State Retirement Disability benefits while he had been out. However, Bearce told city officials he needed to return to work to keep health insurance until he qualified for Medicare in a year and a half, according to Pham’s report.

Rather than return him immediately, the city had Bearce evaluated. It also began paying him again, according to attorney Edward Benjamin, who argued on behalf of the city’s insurer at Monday’s hearing.


“The city wanted a better definition of light duty that he was capable of,” Benjamin said.

As Bearce was undergoing examinations, his cancer returned and the prognosis was that he would be unable to return to work for another year, according to the report by Pham. Bearce was then terminated by the city.

Commissioners voted 3-1 to find reasonable grounds to believe that the city discriminated against him by failing to provide a reasonable accommodation — such as desk work — when he attempted to return.

Bearce, 51, who argued on own behalf at the hearing, said he had a bone marrow transplant 14 months ago and is in full remission, although he is still dealing with health problems, including fatigue.

“I am very glad this part is over with human rights,” Bearce said Tuesday. “I felt I was wronged by the city for not allowing me to come back to work the first time I was in remission.”

Bearce had also accused the city of Waterville of subjecting him to an unlawful medical examination and terminating him because of his physical disability, but the commission voted 4-0 not to support those claims.

In a separate case, commissioners voted 3-1 to find no reasonable grounds that Eric Stewart of Benton was subject to illegal discrimination in employment by Pine View Mobile Homes of Winslow. The vote overturned a recommendation of a commission investigator.


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.