AUGUSTA –– The House of Representatives voted Wednesday to give preliminary approval to a bill that encourages development of solar power in Maine, but final passage remains a longshot.

The House voted 81-69 to advance a bill designed to jump-start an industry that has struggled to gain a foothold in Maine, and in response to a law that could end a key financial incentive for homeowners and businesses that install solar panels on their property. Staunch opposition from Gov. Paul LePage and his allies among House Republicans have doomed the proposal from the start.

That resistance was reflected in Wednesday’s action, as Republicans and two independents voted against the bill.

Advocates for the measure, including solar panel installers in the nascent industry, rallied at the State House in hopes of building support among lawmakers. Supporters said the bill will create 800 new jobs while increasing the supply of solar-generated electricity from 18 megawatts to 250 megawatts, about 2 percent of the state’s power needs. Roughly half of the projected growth would come from homes and small businesses.

Opponents of the bill said it will saddle electricity ratepayers with the costs of subsidizing an industry. The projected impact on ratepayers is disputed.

Mark Vannoy, chairman of the Public Utilities Commission, testified in March that ratepayers could pay a combined $22 million on their electric bills in the fifth year of the plan. The estimate contrasted sharply with the estimates provided by Tim Schneider, the Public Advocate for ratepayers. Schneider said consumers could see a benefit of more than $122 million over the period of the 20-year contract.

The proposal offers a unique approach to net metering, in which utility companies provide a one-to-one credit to solar customers on their bills for power they generate and feed back into the grid. The practice is under fire in other states and the bill, if enacted, would replace the current net metering system with hourly metering and a 20-year price guarantee on the rate that businesses and homeowners are compensated for producing electricity. Such a change would likely make Maine the first state in the country to change to an alternative metering system.


The ratepayer impact dominated the floor debate. Rep. Kenneth Fredette, the House minority leader, attempted to frame the proposal as a freemarket disruption that would inordinately benefit southern Maine residents while financed by poorer, rural residents. Fredette said that he supported renewable energy, but the proposal is “insanity.”

Supporters countered that the bill would help preserve the hundreds of solar installer jobs while encouraging growth in an industry that will further ease Maine’s reliance on fossil fuels and replace lost manufacturing jobs.

The state has roughly 20 megawatts of solar installed now, including 16 megawatts at 1,900 homes and 200 small businesses in Central Maine Power’s service areas.

Republicans have thrown their support behind having the Public Utilities Commission decide the fate of net metering. Advocates of the bill worry that the PUC will eliminate net metering altogether. The three-member commission is comprised of three of the governor’s appointees. LePage has frequently railed against the costs of renewable energy and he has taken a keen interest in defeating the bill, which is sponsored by Democratic Rep. Sara Gideon, the assistant House leader from Freport.

Gideon has said that the bill is a job creator. According to the Solar Foundation, the latest Solar Jobs Census ranked Maine 43rd in the country, with 330 jobs attached to the industry, the largest share of them installers in Cumberland County. Massachusetts was ranked second, with 15,095 jobs.

The proposal requires additional votes in the Senate and House before going to LePage, who has said he will veto the proposal. Overriding the governor requires a two-thirds vote in the House and Senate. The margin in the House was well short of the supermajority that would be needed for an override.


Staff Writer Steve Mistler can be contacted at 620-7016 or at:

[email protected]

Twitter: @stevemistler


Only subscribers are eligible to post comments. Please subscribe or login first for digital access. Here’s why.

Use the form below to reset your password. When you've submitted your account email, we will send an email with a reset code.